How to Tell Whether Your Argument Really Holds Up

How to Tell Whether Your Argument Really Holds Up

Learn how to evaluate claims, identify logical fallacies, and respond calmly to disagreement. Practical techniques can help you sharpen your reasoning and build self-discipline.

When your point of view meets resistance, a simple approach can help: first, state the claim clearly; then examine the reasons behind it; and finally, consider whether the conclusion really follows. These steps don’t have to slow down a discussion—they can make it clearer. This blog offers practical examples of logical fallacies and exercises to help you practise this approach. You’ll find guidance for both thinking things through and expressing a considered response.

Interested in this topic? Read more: Self-discipline in argumentation: How to recognize and avoid logical fallacies on the path to personal growth Want to find out where you stand personally? Take a short test at the end of the page and gain a better understanding.

How does this apply to you? Choose the answers that describe you best:

If someone refers to an authority (e.g., an expert) to support their claim, what does that remind you of?

Choose the answer that best describes you.

What do you think about the argument that says "everyone is doing it, so it must be right"?

Choose the answer that best describes you.

If someone claims that "because something never happened, it must be impossible," what is your first impression?

Choose the answer that best describes you.

If someone argues that "it's not logical because it's not common," what feelings does that evoke in you?

Choose the answer that best describes you.

If someone decides that something is true because it was a long time ago in the past, what significance does that have for you?

Choose the answer that best describes you.

When someone claims, "that's not true because it has never happened in my experience," what do you think about that?

Choose the answer that best describes you.

If someone says, "if it were true, everyone would know it," what do you think about it?

Choose the answer that best describes you.

How do you feel when someone says, "that's true because it's always been done that way"?

Choose the answer that best describes you.

If someone says: "it can't be true because it's too fantastic to be real," what do you think about that?

Choose the answer that best describes you.

When someone uses emotional claims as evidence, what does it evoke in you?

Choose the answer that best describes you.

Argumentative fallacies and logical errors – How to recognize and avoid mistakes in reasoning.

Get an evaluation of your answers

Enter your email to create an account and link this test to it. After you submit all 10 answers, we’ll show your evaluation on the page and email you a link.