Look for confirmation that isn’t just an echo

Look for confirmation that isn’t just an echo

When the same statement appears on several sites, it can look like confirmation. But check whether the sources offer their own evidence or are simply repeating one original article. Ten sites repeating the same unverified post do not necessarily amount to ten independent pieces of evidence. Also note the date of your search if the information may change over time.

Try to find the original statement, document, or record of the event. Then compare how sources with different perspectives describe it. For an important claim, check whether they agree on specific facts or simply use similar headlines. If sources disagree, note exactly where their accounts differ.

Try changing your search terms. Add an organisation’s name, a date, or a document type to the original phrase. You can also search for specific challenges to the claim. The aim is not to find as many pages as possible that agree with you, but to find out what evidence and disagreements exist.

If you can’t tell whether the sources are independent, say so openly. Your conclusion may be provisional: the available information does not yet sufficiently support the claim. That’s more accurate than pretending to be certain.

If you find a contradiction, don’t automatically choose the source that agrees with your opinion. Check whether both sources are referring to the same event and time period.

When might several websites not count as independent confirmation?

Digital Literacy in Practice: How to Verify Information and Make Decisions

Continue the training

Enter your email address to continue the training.