A school’s culture shows when someone disagrees

A school’s culture shows when someone disagrees

At a student council meeting, someone says that breaks are too noisy. Adults respond: “You wouldn’t know how to judge that anyway.” The council was formally given a chance to speak, but its voice meant nothing. Involving people in school life takes more than a survey or a suggestion box. What matters is whether the school listens to the responses, considers them and explains what it did with them.

When gathering feedback from students, parents and staff, distinguish three things: experience, suggestion and decision. A person’s experience matters, but not every proposed solution is feasible. You might say: “We understand that the noise bothers you. We can’t open another corridor right now. We’ll try changing how supervisors are positioned and review the results.” This shows both respect and clear boundaries.

People shouldn’t have to speak publicly about sensitive experiences. Offer a safe channel and explain who will see the information. An anonymous report can point to a problem but may not provide enough detail, so it needs to be checked appropriately. If there’s a threat, discrimination or bullying, a responsible procedure is needed—not just a general discussion.

After gathering feedback, get back to the people who shared it. Even the response “We can’t change this yet, because…” is clearer than silence. Trust grows through the experience of being able to disagree without being ridiculed or given empty promises.

Students make a suggestion the school can’t carry out. How should it respond?

Education in Practice: How to Improve Collaboration, Learning and the School Environment

Continue the training

Enter your email address to continue the training.