Learning from feedback: turn an opinion into a useful next step
Learning from feedback: turn an opinion into a useful next step
A colleague tells you, “You seem unsure when you present.” You might take offence, nod or try to change something. But the comment itself is too vague. The key skill isn’t accepting every criticism as true; it’s working out which information is specific, credible and useful for your next practice. Even well-intentioned advice can be inaccurate.
First, ask for an example: “Which part gave you that impression?” Then check whether it’s an observation or a personal preference. If your colleague says you skipped the conclusion when explaining the results, that gives you something to practise. If they simply don’t like your natural style, you don’t have to change it without further thought. Feedback is information to consider, not a verdict on your worth.
Try one small experiment. In your next presentation, start with the main point, give two reasons and finish by saying what you recommend. Ask a listener to sum up in their own words what they took away. This lets you check whether the change improved understanding, not just whether you came across as confident.
A similar principle works with children and adults: recognise specific effort and explain what to try next. “You’re clever” may feel good, but “You explained the process step by step; now try adding an example” gives someone a way forward. If you feel overwhelmed by feedback, choose just one point. Skills develop through practice and adjustment, not by accumulating advice.