Reading critically means asking the right questions

Reading critically means asking the right questions

When a text is difficult, it can be tempting to memorize its wording and move on. But if you don’t understand the argument, you can’t judge whether the claim applies elsewhere. When you study, distinguish between the main claim, the reason, the example, and the limits of the claim. This approach works with a textbook, an article, or a video lecture. It’s not about doubting everything, but about knowing what a piece of knowledge is based on.

After each paragraph, ask four questions: What exactly is the author claiming? What do they base it on? What example can I think of? When might the claim not apply? If you don’t know the answer, mark the gap. With data, distinguish between a measurement, an interpretation, and a recommendation. When studying course materials, also pay attention to what’s required by the course.

Imagine the statement: “Students with better schedules get better results.” We don’t yet know whether the schedule itself causes the result, or whether other circumstances explain the difference. Don’t automatically treat a relationship as cause and effect. If a source doesn’t explain its method or context, it’s reasonable to acknowledge that the conclusion is limited for now.

When you use several sources, don’t just count how many references you’ve collected. Compare definitions, purpose, and possible contradictions. One textbook might explain a basic rule while another points out an exception. A difference doesn’t necessarily mean one source is wrong; they may be simplifying things to different degrees.

Try writing a short summary: one sentence stating the claim, a second giving the reason, and a third noting a limitation. If you can’t write it without copying, go back to the argument. This helps you develop knowledge you can not only repeat, but also support with reasons.

A textbook says that two things are related. What should you do next?

Learning That Sticks: From Understanding to Independent Use

Continue the training

Enter your email address to continue the training.