Check claims and distinguish them from assumptions

Decisions improve when you know what you don’t know yet

Critical thinking isn’t about finding fault with every statement. It’s about asking what a claim is based on, what assumptions it contains and what might change its conclusion. When you come across a persuasive post or piece of advice, separate the main claim from the evidence. Who created the information? Does it refer to the original source? Is the source relevant to the question you’re dealing with?

For a practical decision, make three columns: what I know, what I assume and what I need to find out. For example, if you’re changing a work process, you may know how many steps the team currently takes but only assume that a new app will save time. A small trial can help you find out whether that assumption holds. For important questions, check information against independent sources that are appropriately trustworthy.

Uncertainty isn’t a flaw you need to hide. You can say, “I can’t confirm this yet; I’ll check the source first.” At the same time, avoid searching endlessly for evidence when a decision is minor and easy to reverse. Match the depth of your checks to the possible consequences of being wrong. For health, financial or legal matters, a general article may not be enough; seek relevant professional help. The aim is to choose an appropriate approach, not to pretend you’re completely certain.

For a claim with potentially serious consequences, decide what evidence would be enough to make a decision and what would make you wait. This helps prevent further searching from serving only to confirm your initial view.

You have a fact and an assumption about the benefits of a workplace change. What’s a sensible next step?

Lifelong Skills: Learning, Thinking and Communicating in Practice

Continue the training

Enter your email address to continue the training.