Critical thinking starts with asking for evidence

Critical thinking starts with asking for evidence

A colleague proposes a new system, saying, “Everyone successful is already using it.” The claim may sound convincing, but you still don’t know who “everyone” is, what “successful” means, or whether the system would solve your problem. Critical thinking doesn’t have to mean disagreeing. It means slowing down and asking questions that separate solid evidence from marketing shorthand, impressions, or appeals to authority.

When you hear an important claim, check four things: What exactly is being claimed? What is it based on? What other explanations are possible? What would change your mind? If someone says, “We’re more efficient with the new tool,” ask what result they’re measuring and what else changed at the same time. Maybe the tool helped; maybe a new way of assigning work did. You don’t have to settle the whole question right away. You do need to know how much uncertainty remains.

Also, don’t assume that a skeptical person has to reject everything. Changing your mind when better information comes along is part of good decision-making. For a small, reversible decision, a proportionate check may be enough. For a decision with major costs or legal or safety implications, you’ll need to examine the evidence more closely and may need expert advice.

In your next discussion, choose one claim that catches your attention. Don’t immediately say, “That’s nonsense.” Try: “What do we know for sure, and what are we still assuming?” If you can also name something that would convince you otherwise, you’re practising genuine evaluation—not just defending your view.

A colleague says a new tool “has improved everyone’s performance.” What’s the best first step?

Skills in Practice: How to Learn, Think, and Work Together

Continue the training

Enter your email address to continue the training.