Feedback students can act on

Feedback students can act on

“You’re clever” might make a student feel good, and “This is poor work” might make them doubt themselves. But neither statement tells them exactly what to repeat or change. Useful feedback focuses on the work, identifies a strength, and points to the next manageable step. It doesn’t judge a person’s worth.

Think of an essay. Instead of “Your writing is chaotic,” try: “Your introduction tells the reader what you’re going to write about. But the second paragraph switches between two topics. Separate them and add one example for each.” The student knows what worked, where the problem arose, and exactly what to do next. Feedback isn’t about leaving lots of comments; sometimes one precise task is more valuable than a long list of criticisms.

Feedback works better when students have a chance to act on it. After giving a comment, set aside a little time for the student to revise a sentence, a calculation step, or an explanation. Then look together to see whether it’s improved. If the student just reads the note and closes the notebook, the chance to learn from it is lost.

When assessing students, separate their performance from their personality, including in conversations with parents. You could say, “They can’t yet complete this type of task independently” instead of “They’re no good at math.” The first statement describes where things stand now and leaves room for progress. Feedback should be honest, clear, and actionable.

Which comment on an essay is the most useful?

Teaching in Practice: How to Guide Learning, Conversations, and Your Own Growth

Continue the training

Enter your email address to continue the training.