Mentoring isn’t renting someone else’s judgment
Mentoring isn’t renting someone else’s judgment
You’re facing a work dilemma and know someone who has been through something similar. You can ask them to talk it over with you. But that doesn’t mean handing over your decision-making. Mentoring means learning from another person’s experience and questions, not having someone decide for you.
A mentor can point out things you may not have noticed, share their own experience, or flag a risk. But you know your values, constraints, and the consequences you’ll have to live with. That’s why “What mattered when you were in that situation?” is more useful than “Exactly what should I do?”
Distinguish mentoring from direct professional advice. If you need someone to review a contract, assess a health issue, or explain specific legal obligations, a mentor’s experience shouldn’t replace a qualified professional. A coaching conversation may rely mainly on questions; a mentor can also openly share their own practice. These approaches can overlap.
Imagine someone who wants to change jobs. Their mentor doesn’t have to tell them which offer to accept. Instead, they can explore how to assess the work environment, which trade-offs to consider, and what information is still missing. This develops the mentee’s judgment—not just their list of advice.
Quick exercise: Write down one question you’d take to a mentor. Then rephrase it so it invites you to understand their experience, rather than asking for a ready-made instruction.