Advice is a hypothesis, not a verdict

Advice is a hypothesis, not a verdict

A mentor says, “If I were you, I’d resign immediately.” It may be an honest opinion based on their past experience. But that doesn’t mean they know all your commitments, financial reserves, or what the job market is like. Good advice needs to be checked against the facts of your situation before you can turn it into a decision.

Break the mentor’s recommendation into three parts: what they actually experienced, how they interpret it, and what they’re proposing you do. These aren’t the same thing. You can respect their experience and still disagree with their conclusion. Saying “I understand your reasoning, but my financial situation is different” isn’t disrespectful.

One useful test is to ask what would need to be true for the recommendation to work. For a job change, for example, there would need to be suitable opportunities, leaving couldn’t put essential commitments at risk, and the new role would need to bring a real improvement. If you don’t know whether those assumptions hold, check them first.

Some advice is easy to test at low cost. You could change how you run a meeting and see how people respond. Other steps are hard to reverse, so they call for more information or perhaps professional advice. Mentoring helps you tell the difference; it doesn’t make uncertainty disappear.

Quick exercise: Think of a piece of advice you’ve received recently. Write down the experience behind it, the assumptions it contains, and one small step you could take to test it safely.

A mentor recommends a major career change but doesn’t know your financial situation. What do you do?

Mentoring in Practice: The Right Questions, Experience, and Independent Decisions

Continue the training

Enter your email address to continue the training.