If you’re a mentor: support without taking control

If you’re a mentor: support without taking control

When someone asks you to mentor them, you may feel pressure to show them the right direction. That’s where a risk arises: instead of helping the other person learn, you start taking more control. A mentor’s role isn’t to create a copy of themselves, but to broaden the options available to someone whose experience is different from their own.

Start by asking, “What have you tried already?” and “What would a good outcome look like to you?” Then you can share your own experience while making its limits clear: “This worked for me, but the circumstances were different.” If the mentee chooses another path, ask about their reasons. Disagreeing with your advice isn’t automatically disobedience.

Be mindful of power differences. If you’re also their manager, evaluator, or someone who decides what opportunities they get, the mentee may stay quiet for fear of the consequences. Clarify your roles and don’t press them to share personal things. Don’t take credit for someone else’s success or promise connections or a promotion that you can’t control.

Being considerate doesn’t mean avoiding challenging questions. You can say, “I notice a gap between what you say you want and what you do. How do you make sense of it?” Ask about behaviour, not a person’s worth. If the mentee needs therapy, legal advice, or specialist support, respect the limits of your role.

Quick exercise: Think of one piece of advice you often give younger colleagues. Reframe it as a question and an example from your own experience, so they don’t leave with only an instruction.

A mentee rejects the mentor’s recommendation but can explain their decision clearly. How should the mentor respond?

Mentoring in Practice: The Right Questions, Experience, and Independent Decisions

Continue the training

Enter your email address to continue the training.