Feedback you can put to use
Feedback you can put to use
“You need to come across as more confident” can leave someone feeling unsure without telling them what to change. Useful feedback describes something someone observed and its effect. For example: “You went off the main point three times during the presentation, so I wasn’t sure what decision you were proposing.” That gives you something to work on.
As a mentee, ask for specific examples: “At what point did you lose track of what I was saying?” or “What was convincing about my argument, and what wasn’t?” Distinguish a description of what happened from a judgement about who someone is. “You interrupted your colleague” can be checked. “You’re arrogant” is a label that needs to be unpacked into specific behaviours.
Accepting feedback doesn’t mean automatically agreeing with it. First listen, summarise it, and check that you’ve understood. If it’s based on inaccurate facts, correct them calmly. If it’s difficult to hear, you can ask for some time to think. A thoughtful response could be: “I understand the example. I need to think about how I’ll take it into account.”
A mentor should also be open to feedback from the mentee. If their examples don’t fit, it makes sense to adjust how you have the conversation. A relationship where questions can only be asked in one direction leaves less room for learning.
Quick exercise: Turn “I’m bad at communicating” into one observable situation and one next step. For example: “I raise my voice quickly when someone disagrees; next time, I’ll first summarise what I understand.”