Good questions bring experience to light

Good questions bring experience to light

A conversation with a mentor can easily turn into a lecture. The mentee brings a problem, the mentor talks about their career, and an hour later it’s still unclear what to take away from it. It helps to prepare questions about how they think, not just questions about the end result.

Instead of “How did you become successful?” try: “What did you know at the time, and what were you only assuming?” Or: “What signs made you change your plan?” These questions reveal the circumstances behind a decision. Someone’s experience from a different time can be valuable, but not every part of it will apply in your setting.

Ask follow-up questions too. When a mentor says, “You need to be more confident,” ask: “What would that look like in one specific conversation?” If they recommend networking, try: “How can you tell a useful relationship from just collecting names?” Ask what words that sound right but may be vague mean in practice.

It’s also important not to reject every suggestion straight away. First, summarise what you heard in your own words: “I understand that you think I don’t prepare enough—is that right?” Then you can add more context or disagree. A mentor can offer a hypothesis; you can test it.

Quick exercise: Before your next conversation, write down one main question, two follow-up questions, and one question about the limits of the recommendation: “When might you take a different approach?”

Which question best helps you apply a mentor’s experience to your own situation?

Mentoring in Practice: The Right Questions, Experience, and Independent Decisions

Continue the training

Enter your email address to continue the training.