Choose a person, not just an impressive résumé

Choose a person, not just an impressive résumé

A high-profile mentor may not be the best guide for you. Someone can be an excellent business owner but struggle to explain their decisions clearly. Someone else may have a more modest profile but know the exact problem you’re facing and be willing to talk openly about it. Relevant experience matters more than prestige alone.

Consider three things when choosing. First: what similar situations has this person experienced firsthand? Second: can they talk about their own mistakes and the limits of what they know? Third: can you disagree with them without worrying about being humiliated? Trust doesn’t require agreement, but it does require room for respectful disagreement.

Check their availability. A mentor who can realistically manage one conversation a month may be more useful than a well-known person who repeatedly cancels. If you’ll be discussing sensitive work information, also consider conflicts of interest, whether they’re your manager, and the possible consequences of sharing details.

Treat the first conversation as a chance to see if you’re a good fit for each other. Explain your goal, ask for their perspective, and notice whether they ask about the context. If they immediately offer one-size-fits-all solutions, you can ask: “When might this approach not work?” Their answer can tell you a lot about their judgment.

Quick exercise: Choose two potential mentors and compare their experience, willingness to listen, and actual availability. Put their name or job title last on your list of criteria.

Which criterion should matter most when choosing a mentor?

Mentoring in Practice: The Right Questions, Experience, and Independent Decisions

Continue the training

Enter your email address to continue the training.